NameSilo

news ICANN security group warns against Emoji domain names

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch
For what it's worth to those following, investing or thinking of, in emoji domains -
Emoji domain names have received some press over that last year thanks, in part, to .ws allowing registrations of emoji domain names.

Now, the ICANN Security and Stability Advisory Committee (SSAC) has published a report (pdf) warning against the use of these domain names.

The brief report notes that emoji in domain names are not allowed under the Internationalized Domain Names in Applications (IDNA) standard. They aren’t universally accepted and do not work across all devices.

They can also be difficult to decipher. Many emoji look similar to each other and some emoji can be “glued” together using a special zero width joiner (ZWJ) code point.

This creates a major problem:

The whole point of an identifier is to specify something unambiguously—this thing, as distinct from all other things. To a user, a single unmodified emoji might look exactly the same as its “glued together” counterpart, and systems that do not support emoji composition using a ZWJ will display the individual components of a “glued together” emoji as a sequence of separate emoji, with results that may visually be very different from what was intended. This is acceptable for interpersonal communication, particularly when it is augmented by shared context, but it is not acceptable for Internet identifiers, particularly DNS root labels that must be unambiguously resolved independent of any context.
http://domainnamewire.com/2017/05/27/icann-security-group-warns-emoji-domain-names/
 
6
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
3
•••
1
•••
So the SSAC report , in this case, says because everything doesnt work exactly right, lets warn and not allow any emoji new tlds (to the right of the dot)

This could be the moment like with Bitcoin went before Congress, who held hearings and warned on the risk of Bitcoin, and that moved everyone to say what is bitcoin... and led to huge popularity

some of the assumptions are spot on on why the marketplace is moving toward these names

REPORT: Emoji are “pictographs (pictorial symbols) that are typically presented in a colorful cartoon form and used inline in text

my thoughts yup, pretty cool

REPORT They are popular on smartphones, in chat, in email applications, and in social media, where they are part of a trend toward pictorial forms of communication to augment (or replace) text

my thoughts - so lets definately keep them out of the internet naming system, we only allow changes when we make $300,000,000

and then this pretty accurate summary -

REPORT - Some country code Top Level Domains (ccTLDs), e.g., .WS (Samoa) and .LA (Laos), allow domain names with emoji to be registered at the second level, and several registrars accept labels with emoji for registrations in other TLDs. Since 2011, at least one browser displays any emoji it recognizes when they appear in domain names, although other browsers continue to show the ASCII A-labels instead

ME - cool which browser? BTW .LA does not currently allow emoji, does have some grandfathered including the poop emoji..

REPORT - Since most applications implement either the current version of IDNA (IDNA2008), the obsolete previous version (IDNA2003), or some locally synthesized combination of the two, the practical implication is that domain names with emoji will not be accepted or processed consistently by applications.

me - so not universal, growing pains, and these workarounds work pretty good in most cases, i think of emoji in beta when it comes to use right now, - you have keyboards, browsers and different rendering but each domain name still resolves to one set of nameservers...even if some outputs look the same... whic of course could change if the base person emojis become different than the genders. funny how pouting was assumed to be a woman, ...

so looks like emoji will stay out of new and existing global tlds until its ready for prime time.

and the market will move toward education and more and more use, with disclaimers for beta and not the same level of complete universal resolution...im in.
 
5
•••
signboard-thank-you-smiley-emoticon.gif
for posting this.
 
0
•••
If the public want emoji domains they'll buy them irrespective of wether they are allowed or not

www.xn--74m.com

Click link to see emoji

Only just bought it
 
0
•••
not sure thats an emoji, just chinese character, do you see it on the apple or twitter keyboard?
 
0
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back