OP closed the thread where I was winning. Opened up a new thread. Went to arbitration. It was decided that I won the domain fairly. OP still decided not to transfer the domain. We don't need cheaters like this on NamePros. He should be banned IMHO.
It's always great when newbies buy from newbies, learning en route! He was communicating well and is becoming a domaining professional fast. A highly recommended seller.