Ok, so you have also answered your own question in a way.
you got it appraised? By who? I can't think of anyone around here that believes in automated appraisals to any degree. The only one that people grudgingly accept as maybe slightly ok is estibot.
So let's say you got an appraisal up to $200.
How many people have offered you that?
How many people have offered you $80?
If you REALLY want to know, put it in the auction section with all your factors, and start the bidding at $1. You will find out by the end of the auction what it is worth.
My guess would be around $55-$75 at best.