Well, the hyphen kills it only if you were expecting to handreg a $500k name.
It is what it is, which is one of the best hand regged *domaining* names I've seen.
I would keep it & set it up as a master reseller site.
Sell domain & hosting reseller accts to other people.
Then everytime one of 'your' resellers signs up a customer, you get a little cut.
You can do this with GD, reseller.biz, OpenSRS, and a few others.
Value = high $xxx to low $x,xxx.
I know the appraisers that follow me in this thread will probably howl about my valuation & whine about the hyphen.
But I challenge them to go and hand reg a better domaining name.