Let me write my appraisal of these names and see if that spurs any convo . . . so I can better gauge what I have here.
Identical word search per google is very low for both domains. This is a negative.
Word search (Broadway probably does it) is very strong. This is a plus.
Both Broadway Eats and Broadway Treats are very brandable. This is a plus.
I think they can go into multiple directions. Obviously foods. Broadway Sweets is already registered, and looks to be in the low XXXX range. The exact word mach is marginally more than my two names, but my non exact word match smashes the non exact word match with sweets!
I think the word treats could go in a gifting merchandise direction as well.
Id say, domains may never sell . . .
Low XXXX seems like a decent price to list them at . . .