It is a very good GEO, but legal domains are not easy sales from my experience. They are especially hard to sell proactively for top dollar.
Another issue is the variations. You have New York, NY, and NYC as well as boroughs and surrounding areas. You also have lawyer, lawyers, attorney, attorneys, etc.
I would just be content to sit on it with a low 5 figure asking price and renew it until I got a serious offer.
Brad