I think it is an excellent grab and I am surprised you got it!
First off we have 'God' one of the top searched for terms on the internet. Then I am sure a high percentage of those use the word 'tonight' in their search terms.
"What would God do Tonight"
Conversations
"I need God in my heart Tonight."
I think the domain itself would be high $xx.
But with some development (Throw on a blog with a post every week regarding a sermon or something God changed for you and BOOM instant hits, tons of visitors and much much MUCH more value appeal to your audience) this domain could really fetch some money.
Develop it for a month with a couple things and you could easily find a buyer even on here for the low-mid $xxx's