Except the only flaw in that plan is that I called (who I now assume was Cass herself) and she hung up on me. And then she didn't answer my next call, which is why I say someone else should call.
Here's the basic timeline of what happened:
3-5 Days Ago (Not exactly sure when): My site goes down. PM and email Cassandra for support. Email bounces back.
2 Days Ago: Other NPers start pointing out that they are hosted with Cassandra as well, and that their sites are down, thus showing that her server has been suspended, deleted, or is broken.
1 Day Ago: I realize that Cassandra's website, divine-hosting.com, is now parked on eNom.
Today, 2 PM: I see that my sites are still down and that Cassandra hasn't been on NP in days, so I assume the worst. I call ev1.net to see if anyone can help, but they say without specific verification information, there is nothing they can do.
Today, 2:30 PM: I decide to call the number listed on her whois information. A woman picks up, I ask for Cassandra, she asks who is calling, I tell her "someone she's hosting," she says hold on and then a few seconds later I realize she hung up on me.
Today, 2:45PM: I call the number back (who I now assume is Cassandra herself) and no one picks up. I get a voicemail but don't leave a message.
Today, 3:15PM: I decide to call ev1.net back realizing that she's scammed us. This new lady I talk to seems a lot more willing to help, but she says the guy I need to talk to is on a business call, so she takes a message. I also find out around this time that BensonTwenty was backing her and hasn't been on NP in December yet, either.
So I am now awaiting a call back from ev1, if they don't call back tonight I'll give them a call tomorrow and then leave a voicemail at Cassandra's number.