Tables or CSS?

B

BigMoney

Account Closed (Disallowed)

Impact

0

• Jun 13, 2005

• #2

Tables existed in HTML for one reason: To display tabular data. But then border="0" made it possible for designers to have a grid upon which to lay out images and text. Still the most dominant means of designing visually rich Web sites, the use of tables is now actually interfering with building a better, more accessible, flexible, and functional Web.

What's Good About CSS?
-Accessibility
-Less Code
-Ability to change the Appearance quickly

 

T

Tha_Bee

Guest

Guest

• Jun 13, 2005

• #3

wow...CSS after my opinion doesn't meen you should not use tables, you should use css to format tables, but tabels are indispensable in web pages, or if you don't want to use tables u can use layers ,is the same s**t.........thats what i think.

 

B

BigMoney

Account Closed (Disallowed)

Impact

0

• Jun 13, 2005

• #4

i dont think there are surfers left using browsers older than 4.0 i.e.

 

C

CompMaster

Guest

Guest

• Jun 13, 2005

• #5

:P

Yea...I think css is better, *I* think it's easier to compile and just easier to change the appearance of the whole site...

:P

 

T

Tha_Bee

Guest

Guest

• Jun 13, 2005

• #6

CSS is much better

 

B

BigMoney

Account Closed (Disallowed)

Impact

0

• Jun 13, 2005

• #7

Better CSS beacuse especially if you have big site
For example you need to change something.... in just one line you can change whole site look .

 

T

Tha_Bee

Guest

Guest

• Jun 13, 2005

• #8

I think this is the main reason whay i'm using CSS, also u can separate css from html file so it's cleaner, but with css there are problems with broswers, or should i say broswers have problem with css

 

A

ASSistance

Account Closed (Disallowed)

Impact

0

• Jun 13, 2005

• #9

Frankly, I don't understand the animosity toward tables that CSS designers regularily exhibit.

Okay, I understand that div elements are a real treat for the CSS freak, but you can still put your CSS around your table and make it do what you want.

And when it comes to divs within divs, it's no different than tables within tables. If anything, it's more difficult to pull off, and I don't see why anyone would waste a perfectly good and working table element in favor of the div.

 

B

BigMoney

Account Closed (Disallowed)

Impact

0

• Jun 13, 2005

• #10

and the code is much cleaner ,who could manage with all those tables
table in table and so on...

 

T

Tha_Bee

Guest

Guest

• Jun 13, 2005

• #11

actually if u have a large site the table design really sucks. but this doesnt mean that this kind of design shouldn't be used.
personally i use both of them. the question div or table i ask myself on the first stage of design.

and i think that the thread`s title is wrong. it should be div or table, not css or table

 

Rowan W

Established Member

★ 20 ★

Impact

9

• Jun 13, 2005

• #12

http://www.hotdesign.com/seybold/index.html

 

R

realtechtalk

Established Member

★ 20 ★

Impact

0

• Jun 14, 2005

• #13

ASSistance said:

Why is it better to use CSS instead of TABLES? Also .. XHTML or HTML validation is any good? :p

Click to expand...

Everyone's made good arguments for and against tables. I think if you are just starting out and you aren't familiar with CSS then use tables but realize CSS offers more flexibility but has the issue of different browsers mainly IE and Non-IE displaying the page differently in some cases.

Cheers

 

W

WebbyMedia

Established Member

★ 20 ★

Impact

0

• Jun 15, 2005

• #14

You shouldn't mess with tables any more. Mastery of CSS will pay big dividends a few years down the road.

 

StudioWorks

no one lives foreverVIP Member

VIP

★ 20 ★

Impact

73

• Jun 15, 2005

• #15

Well I stopped using tables for a while now. CSS rules!

- DM

 

barefoottech

Aussie MINISITE KingTop Member

VIP

★ 20 ★

Impact

456

• Jun 15, 2005

• #16

One of the main Advantages of CSS and Alternate StyleSheets is to allow Flexibility to Display the same Data on Different Devices .
Usage of CellPhones,PDA's,WebTV's and other Similiar Devices to View the Internet requires it.
Tables are OK For PC Display ,but try using them on a Cellphone Display .

 

whyme953

Established Member

★ 20 ★

Impact

1

• Jun 15, 2005

• #17

IMHO one of the disadvantages of CSS is its "moodiness" sometimes it does work, sometimes it doesnt. granted, many times the problems are not with the CSS rather with the browsers, however, i've had times when i use the same exact script on 2 pages and one works and the other doesnt (e.g. i write that script in its own file and it displays properly but when i put that code into the page where it belongs it doesnt work)

for me its still tables for now.

 

N

NickRac

Yes.VIP Member

VIP

★ 20 ★

Impact

35

• Jun 17, 2005

• #18

stick w/ CSS - works better IMHO