What you are saying is right. But no other tld is gonna beat the. Com market as its always the top preference by anyone apart from their regional domain tld.
But may be in the long term these new tld's may get a professional value.
Its not the highest ranking from my location. Though Its showing up at 5th position.
Its ranking in the first page because of the keyword match in the domain name and also the title and on page.
Domain: bachelorsonly.com
Expiration Date: 2015-10-26
Registrar: 1&1
Starting Bid: $100
Bid Increments: $5
End Time: 72 hours after the last bid or 5 days if no bid
Payment Options: Paypal/skrill
Domain: Xferonline.com (Transfer Online)
Expiration Date: 2015-10-26
Registrar: 1and1
Starting Bid: $ 100
Bid Increments: $5
End Time: 72 hours after the last bid or 5 days if no bid
Payment Options: Paypal/skrill
Domain: webmarshals.net
Expiration Date: 2015-10-08
Registrar: PDR LTD. D/B/A PUBLICDOMAINREGISTRY.COM
Starting Bid: $ 300
Bid Increments: $5
End Time: 72 hours after the last bid or 7 days if no bid
Payment Options: Paypal/skrill
Age of the domain might help if the site planned is relevant to the previous sites on the same domain as the backlinks to that domain would bring potential leads/readers to the site.