IT.COM

.mobi .MOBI is a scam and suckers are paying to get in line.

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch
Impact
26
WOW, look at the money going for mobi names. More and more selling everyday and for good money. What a time for domain speculators and web polluters.

I am kinda confused how or why people think this names will be worth anything after this initial bubble of sales pops?

Have any of yall ever used your phone for the internet? I have a nokia 7710 and can access the full net with any domain and dont need a special tld to allow me to use it. HMM, last time I checked cell phones get more advanced, not less so why would anyone think there needs to be special domain for that.

HMM, could it be the seach companies who want you to use there engine, the ones behind .mobi? I use google.com/pda for search and last week they just started showing ads. There is even a mobile web button to search with, I wonder why?? DOES google own part of mobi, naw thats not it. All new tlds sell for outragous amounts when they 1st come out dont they?? NOPE, just ones with search engines and large corps behind them.

What about browser detection??? Is that something that doesnt work anymore? You type in www.freeredboxcodes.com in the box on your phone and wow it detects what browser your on and directs you to www.freeredboxcodes.com/mobile which has removed all the pop ups and bs and gives the content the user wanted.

Has anyone read what the requirements are to develop the actual site code?
http://www.w3.org/TR/2006/WD.mobile-bp-20060113/
http://pc.mtld.mobi/documents/dotmobi-Switch-On!-Web-Browsing-Guide.html

UM, the purpose is to provide quick and concise info on screen so small that there is to be limited graphics and limited number of links. SO you want to pay big money for a name that wont have ads because there isnt room to view them. Now dont get me wrong, I am in no way mad at the people selling these names for big money. I would do the same. But to think that these will be worth a lot is insane. I see all these names and typos being bought and sold and I really dont think that they understand how a phone internet user uses the net.

How many are going to pay 60.00 a month to get high speed access? I dont think many and those that do already are using good web capable phones, ie Treo or other smartphone. Ok so they are using the GPRS or whatever mode offered which is equal to dial up. How many of you surf the net on dial up?? Wont happen. You would look up the ONE bit of info you needed and get offline.
When exactly are you going to use your phone to surf the net? As you drive, at your desk, in the car ride home?? The net on your phone is a standby luxury that I can use to look up movies or the spur of the monent trivia answer at the dinner table.

I dont think that the implentation will be effective to anyone but the resellers of the names and the mobi'esqe info. How many people are going to surf smurfs.mobi as they drive because they have that instant need to learn the names of Gargamels cat. The names with the direct names might work, phonebook, movies, info, stuff like that. OH wait when I had horrible nextel they had mobile net and I could selct from a menu numbered 1-10 with the same headings. It would give me local info and as slow and as bad as it looked it worked for that spur of the monent need for information.

My one .mobi is adultclips.mobi and well there is nothing up yet. Since the only thing the net is good for is porn, there is no reason not to think that the phone will be used to get that also. I tried to find the line up for the 1986 Houston Rockets and searched everyway possible and didnt find anything, but if I looked for black midget lesbian jello wrestling I could find it no problem.

In conclusion lol, you know you like reading this dribble, names with a use that can be attributed to cell phones will be used and probably prosper. I just read sportsbook.mobi sold for 6 figures. Maybe I am thinking only USA, maybe in the rest of the world they will use the .mobi differently. Degenerate gamblers have there passcode and the 1-800 memorized so I cant see them using the phone to place there bets. I am not jealous or anything like that so people dont go off on me for sounding like a hater. I am just a stater and to see these names sell for so much and to see people hyping this up when this is just as bad as .us or .gs. The only difference is that google and everyone else isnt behind .gs. ANyone selling scam.mobi, I'll take it.
 
0
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
Hi pluto459

I have read through your 12 posts you have made since you have been a member and if I did not know any better I would think someone scammed you at some time in your domain life.

You seem very angry or hurt?
 
0
•••
0
•••
Think what you want, I have done my homework & you have done yours. Vision is in the 'BRAIN' of the beholder! :hehe:
 
Last edited:
0
•••
I agree with you pluto459, but mobi domains are a commodity and therefore there is money to be made. What the future is one can only speculate.
 
0
•••
"Since the only thing the net is good for is porn..."

Are you really that ignorant?

Wow...

And FYI, there already are .mobi sites with ads on them. If you want to have an intelligent discussion about the pros and cons of this or any extension, thats fine, but this post is so flaming that even my keyboard is hot right now. Do some research, find a clue, and try again.
 
0
•••
eJRB said:
Think what you want, I have done my homework & you have done yours. Vision is in the eye of the beholder!

Actually vision is in the brain, eye just sees it :hehe:
 
0
•••
rickkumar said:
Actually vision is in the brain, eye just sees it :hehe:
:lol: :hehe:
 
0
•••
Pluto, here is a few tips,

-Obviously an extension can't be a “scam” so after once glance at the heading it unlikely many people with bother reading your post.
-The grammar and spelling in your post is terrible with rambling content. If readers make it past the heading it is unlikely such poor written post would be persuasive.
-The issue has been done to death, probably better joining in one of the existing threads.
 
0
•••
todalen said:
Hi pluto459

I have read through your 12 posts you have made since you have been a member and if I did not know any better I would think someone scammed you at some time in your domain life.

You seem very angry or hurt?

Hmmm, 12 posts and you read them all and I'm hurt lol.
Nope, never scammed and if we judge by the # of posts well you have issues. I think you had 12 posts at one time also.

seanboy said:
"Since the only thing the net is good for is porn..."

Are you really that ignorant?

Wow...

And FYI, there already are .mobi sites with ads on them. If you want to have an intelligent discussion about the pros and cons of this or any extension, thats fine, but this post is so flaming that even my keyboard is hot right now. Do some research, find a clue, and try again.

Research huh. Give me the domains ao I can pull them up on my phone and see them load. Oh my fault, the net is also good for forums so people can sit around and post about the posts that were posted lol.

What phone are you using to pull up these sites with so i can try that out to see the ads.
 
0
•••
seanboy said:
Here we go again...

Naaa, it's all good ... and I, as a single .MOBI owner too, don't disagree with several points - rough as they appear, at first blush - made by pluto IMHO. :gl:

For me, I like to hear all opinions! :imho:
Thanks.
-Jeff B-)
 
0
•••
snoop said:
Pluto, here is a few tips,

-Obviously an extension can't be a “scam” so after once glance at the heading it unlikely many people with bother reading your post.
-The grammar and spelling in your post is terrible with rambling content. If readers make it past the heading it is unlikely such poor written post would be persuasive.
-The issue has been done to death, probably better joining in one of the existing threads.


NICE, feel free to utilize your degree in English to correct any grammar you dont like. I am glad you did read it so the rambling was ok if you got to the end and commented. I do appreciate comments, isnt that what this forum is for? To discuss things.

Cant be a scam huh. WOW, the juice is with big business. How far did the .xxx get? I guess if google was in on it and not booble.com it would have started up.
 
0
•••
mobis 4 all

Pluto , I like to look at the positives and negatives and sure mobi is a risk but:

Risks::

*Buying the Google IPO at $ 85 hmm now it's $500
*Buying dot coms in the late 90's hmm now we all wish we bought more
*Buying a $1,000 worth of Microsoft stock in the early 80's now worth over a million now
*Naysayers that never take a risk but usually always say should have, could have, would have .

Time will tell and hopefully you will eat your words
 
0
•••
This is too funny and a bit suspicious. Labrocca, is that you under a diferent account name??? Come on, it has to be, the timing is amazing. :wave:
 
0
•••
Ok we all can voice our opions on this site, but we dont have to agree with everyone. Value is in the eye of the beholder. Who can argue with the money some are making but most will not be so lucky. This is also the case for any extension even .com. I am sure there are lots of people who have lost money on all extensions. Its all about marketing for .mobi I own many .mobi but most of the people i know outside the domain world have never heard of .mobi and this needs to be changed.
 
0
•••
It's not me. I don't do pseudonyms. Besides his membership date was in December.
 
1
•••
mobi

Wow....The comments and opinions on this topic very to great degree. I am still amazed at the number of people who are looking for a miracle. Yes, things do happen that we do not expect. However, the reality is that this extension for wide use is not going to happen. It doesn't make sense for wide general use. Even Rick who bought flowers.mobi for 200K has said that. The extension only works with certain names as Pluto459 has mentioned...Phonebooks? Flowers? Pizza? Porn?

I applaud everyone who has sold a .mobi name as i did not buy any names for resale. However, I would recommend that you take your money and run if you can. This pony will not place in this race.

Anyone who thinks can.mobi, dog.mobi, and fun.mobi are worth BIG money, i would challenge you on that and feel bad if you bought those for good money.

The application and intention for the .mobi extension is limited and time will demonstrate that. I think that Pluto459 is more correct then alot of you guys with 20 .mobi's in your portfolio with names like THR.mobi saying .mobi is going to be HUGE, it might be, but for 100 subjects and 1000 domain names.
 
Last edited:
0
•••
steven22 said:
Anyone who thinks can.mobi, dog.mobi, and fun.mobi are worth BIG money, i would challenge you on that and feel bad if you bought those for good money.

Fun.mobi not worth big money??? I laughed so hard I almost fell off my chair. :) :hehe: :) :yell: :'(
 
0
•••
Steven you are right. However just because you don't see the potential of fun.mobi doesn't mean another company doesn't. I would argue that fun.mobi is easily a $xx,xxx name if only going by the current market. Is it all justified pricing? Probably not but it's the pricing. We pay $3 a gallon for gas that could be $1.

btw
ovt for fun 189,735 <---that's a big number for ovt

I think a market adjustments is coming but doubtful it will be within 3-6 months. I have a feeling (oh gawd I sound like you mobists) that the new traffic will push mobi further. Each big sale only pushed mobi the bigger heights which inevitably lead to a bigger fall....the questions are when do you get in...and when do you get out?
 
0
•••
0
•••
pluto459 said:
Cant be a scam huh. WOW, the juice is with big business. How far did the .xxx get? I guess if google was in on it and not booble.com it would have started up.

It really makes no sense to call an extension a scam, it would be like calling a car a scam or a pair of jeans a scam. The way something is sold might be a scam, but not the item itself.

steven22 said:
Anyone who thinks can.mobi, dog.mobi, and fun.mobi are worth BIG money, i would challenge you on that and feel bad if you bought those for good money.

It sold for 100k via auction, are you saying that if it were put up for auction again tomorrow it would get a lot less?
 
0
•••
I don't know if its worth arguing with someone who thinks the internet is only good for porn.
 
0
•••
seanboy said:
I don't know if its worth arguing with someone who thinks the internet is only good for porn.

Wouldn't want to use his keyboard and mouse :hehe:
 
0
•••
tophatter said:
Pluto , I like to look at the positives and negatives and sure mobi is a risk but:

Risks::

*Buying the Google IPO at $ 85 hmm now it's $500
*Buying dot coms in the late 90's hmm now we all wish we bought more
*Buying a $1,000 worth of Microsoft stock in the early 80's now worth over a million now
*Naysayers that never take a risk but usually always say should have, could have, would have .

Time will tell and hopefully you will eat your words

There is no comparison between stock and the .mobi domains.
Mobi is like the penny stocks on the pink sheets.

I am not inversted in the names and didnt plan on speculating on them. I see others that are and just concerned about the newbies that came along trying to get rich buying LLL.mobi's as investment.
 
0
•••
It sold for 100k via auction, are you saying that if it were put up for auction again tomorrow it would get a lot less?

No, the .mobi market is very strong right now. The name might go for more tomorrow. That is not my point. My point is flash forward 12-18 months and that name like 98% of the other .mobi names will be worth a lot less. Just because people are investing in the extension doesn't mean it will be a success. Again, a small number of sites have the potential to be useful in a meaningful manner that warrant sales in this price range.
 
0
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back