One of the domains I backordered went to auction. I'm not sure if I was the only backorder. There was one other $25 bid, but it was hours after mine. So it could be their backorder system took awhile to process it, or someone bid once the auction...
The new $50 minimum fee is going to price them out of a lot of smaller dollar domain transactions. $10 on a $200 transaction was good. $50 on a $200 transaction is crazy.
The only benefit I can see to using their broker service is if you really want the domain, it's registered with GoDaddy, and you've been unable to contact the owner yourself. GoDaddy's domain owner contact form has limited options. It's not...
You already listed it for sale. I'm not sure how them offering to buy it at the listed price would be considered further bad faith, if your domain is infringing.
Asking for more money would be a bad idea.
Also, ask yourself, do they already...
That's not what this says:
https://www.godaddy.com/domains/domain-backorder
states if you are the only backorder holder, you become the domain name registrant.
That's why I backordered the domain. I would have never spent money with you for...