Just my 2 cents:
I like them both, especially "acting in new york", because it has 110 searches a month on EXACT KEYWORD Matches with a $3.49 cpc.. (cost per click) ratio...with high competition.
I am somewhat a newbie, but have been studying hard and long, everyday at this...But I think they are great names.
5k runners also have an exact keyword match on it, and is shorter, (which is good)...But no cpc listed... If you have a target audience to sell to for that, I think that's great! However, I don't know much about 5k running, and who I would reach out to for that would be extremely limited.
One thing you really want to consider besides the keywords, and the cpc on them is who is your target audience to sell to...And would those people have the budget to spend on what you want to get?
I think Acting in New York is very targetable, but I don't know who you would target for 5k runners, maybe the olympics?
The only thing I don't like about "acting in new york" is that it is long, and 4 words...I tend to only stick with 3 words at the very MAX, and try to keep it under 10 characters...But on the flip side it is a long tail keyword with a good cpc..The higher the cpc is on a name you have, the better, especially with exact matches....I think it's worth a bit more than mid-high xxx, if you find the right buyer, and your selling, and negotiating abilities, but that's just my opinion.
Anyhow, It's only worth what the buyer is willing to pay, and your selling abilities, and negotiating.
I wouldn't go by any appraisals at all, as like I said, it's only worth what the potential buyers think it is.
Keep reading, watching videos, and learning,
EVERY DAY, If you're serious about getting in this business, then stick to your gut instinct on them, and
don't let anyone discourage you! However, be able to take Constructive criticism, but weed out the constructive, from the DEstructive, and eliminate all destructive!...As you don't need negativity sticking to you! You have to stay positive, and surround yourself with positive people in order to sell..(But,another story, for another time.)
When you see the value in something, and are planning to proactively sell to your targets, rather than other domainers, allow your potential buyers to see the value you see....I think, however, these names speak for themselves...Set your prices, and know what the lowest you're willing to take, and stick to it. People will try to lowball you, so be able to know what type of budget they have, what value this domain would have for them, how much business, and what value they would have from this domain, and set your prices accordingly. If it was something like "making crafts", I wouldn't expect to sell that high, because their isn't a lot of money in making crafts, (unless your my grandmother..but that's another story, and a rare find..)
Anyhow, if you still see value in it...Hold onto it for a year or 2, and if you only get 1 offer in that entire year, when you are being proactive in selling, then I would say, take the offer, and let it go, and perhaps look at things from a different perspective.
Another tip: Only invest on what you can afford to lose, like you're walking into a casino.
Be sure to also look at names that are selling, and figure out why they would sell for that, why would someone want to pay xxxxx for that particular name. ( I, personally know some things first hand about some business owners, that most people don't, as I worked with many, for many years and consulted, and sold to..But not willing to share..lol..)
Anyhow, Study the names over time, and I think you will do fine.
I do agree with "inforg" that if you're going to sell to other domainers, then yes, mid-high xxx, would probably be what it's worth..If that! With other domainers, I would expect a lot less...
However, I think your selling abilities come into play a lot, and if your target audience sees the same value in a name that you do, then you're onto something great!
This game is not only about doing research on each of your names, but picking really good ones, and all about being able to sell, negotiate, and reach out to your target audience. I think you're off to a good start!
Good Luck!
