- Impact
- 311
Just getting the feeling of what members want.
so can you confirm if *you* post a sales thread and someone comes in and says... hey shit name would you be ok with this new openess?
Just a recap of the above Test... that goes with the below comments....For those of you requesting more transparency between Staff & Members, the following is a thread I closed, updated transparently, and left visible to serve as a test in transparency. This is what full transparency looks like, is this what you are wanting? http://www.namepros.com/domains-for-sale-make-offer/744015-union-ca.html
(Please note, the comments in the sales thread were left on purpose for this test, normally we remove them as they are not allowed as per the marketplace rules "All questions / comments should be sent via PM")
Eric Lyon
Member Services
I can understand the frustration of not knowing what when where and why. Another option to openness is to have PM's automatically sent to users that had posts removed / deleted showing them the reason For comment. This would allow us to continue to prevent Thread crashing posts in your sales threads.Now that is EXACTLY what I want from Namepros.
I've posted a thread or two that disappeared. No PM, no notice, nothing... it was just gone. I thought it was a glitch so I posted it again. This got me yelled at by a mod because I should "know better" and I should somehow just know to check the dead thread forum. I didn't know where these posts got moved to, there was no reference to it. Finally found the dead thread section buried in a sub-sub-forum waaaaay at the bottom of namepros.
That was just one of the issue I've had with the forum, which caused me to post here less and visit less. I even went so far as to set up my own forum.
Transparency is definitely a step in the right direction.
In reference to a Thread crashing comments, I agree, those should continue to be removed.That comment would be deleted - not the whole thread, right?
It sounds good in theory to be ok with thread crashing comments, but I think once members get a potential buyer ready to spend the x,xxx and then change their mind at the last minute because someone just posted in the same thread about how the name is garbage & should only be worth xx & that the seller is unrealistic. That member may get a bit upset they lost the sale due to the comment. Don't you think?I would absolutely be OK with that.
Just getting the feeling of what members want.
so can you confirm if *you* post a sales thread and someone comes in and says... hey shit name would you be ok with this new openess?
Ok great and I hope you speak for the mass because if this is what you all really want.. then please do not send reported threads or pms to mods asking them to delete posts in our sales threads that say..
This name is crap
Be careful what you wish for.. YES there is room to change, YES there are always things that can be done better but do you really want a free for all here..
I very much doubt it ...
Which post was that in response too?
Can you PM me, someone else on member services, or an Admin with an example of that so we can look into it?Discussion threads, need to be more relaxed tho, there is some overmodding happening in those areas.
Just getting the feeling of what members want.
so can you confirm if *you* post a sales thread and someone comes in and says... hey sh*t name would you be ok with this new openess?
...professionalism dictates that proper usage of language be utilized, so no, I would feel that using expletives per your example denigrates the thread as well as the forum as a whole.
There are a myriad of alternatives one can use to cast a negative opinion of a domain name without resorting to vulgarities...one should also explain the reasons that they do not like the name as well instead of a "rubber stamp" post that states their disapproval...
wanted opions/apraisals I agree If they ask they should not be offended with the comments.... but I have had many whom think ALL threads (including sales) should be open to comment which is what I was saying above... No if someone is wanting to sell something I do not think their thread should be open to comments.
Agreed but do you think your average domainer would use such language?
I would be okay with that too. But that's only because I already know my names are shit. :tu: Well that and I think it'd be funny to make fun of newbies that post insane asking prices for crap domains. It's a good way to learn a lesson.
Yes, there are lots of crazy opinions on this forum.
On another note....
I think RJ made an extremely wise decision in selling this forum.
The real problem is not the moderation but the changes taking place on the Internet in general. The art of Domaining is dying. I think in order for this forum to have any hope for long term survival and possible growth, it will need to expand into wider subject areas.
There are several possibilities, but it will obviously need to be "name" related.
Ideas: (aka possible forum areas)
- Personal names (first, last, history, meaning, popularity)
- Domain names (complete history of an extinct activity)
- Business names (discussion of business names, inc, co, corp)
- Pet names (history, meaning, cat names, dog names, fish names)
Basically the home page will show big buttons with entrances into each forum category. I foresee traffic and ad revenue quadrupling within 24 months.
Can you PM me, someone else on member services, or an Admin with an example of that so we can look into it?
Alternately, you can start a thread Here that Only member Services & Admins have access to: http://www.namepros.com/contact-np-member-services/
Thanks,
Eric Lyon
Member Services
Believe it or not, there's literally 100's of thousands upon more thousands of threads in the Ask A Mod section. If you could PM me with the links to your reports (To speed up the process) I'll check them out personally.Just look at my Ask A Mod threads. I touched on a couple of examples above. In the 3d thread, talking about 3d, I linked to a Gizmodo article talking about 3d - http://gizmodo.com/5536087/the-next-playboy-centerfold-will-be-in-3d
I got flagged for spamming for that, some of my first posts on this forum. I guess somebody had a problem with Gizmodo talking about Playboy or something but it was relevant to the discussion, there are no videos of people screwing on Gizmodo. And for me to be flagged for spamming, usually I would have to be connected to that site, Gizmodo, somehow. Not my site, obviously.
The other example I touched on was in the .co discussion thread. Somebody was talking about major merchants using .co. I pointed out the top 500 merchants aren't, the one that was, backed down from the extension. I linked to this page - http://www.internetretailer.com/top500/list/ so people could see, top merchants aren't using that extension. It was relevant to the conversation.
The post was removed, with somebody thinking I was dropping affiliate links.
That kind of thing. People having discussions (what a forum is for) and a mod coming in and removing posts for no good reason. There were no rules violations anywhere. There are more examples in the Ask A Mod forum, maybe the new owner can take a look.
Not sure if posted yet but:
The Next Playboy Centerfold Will Be In 3D
-gizmodo.com/5536087/the-next-playboy-centerfold-will-be-in-3d- [link removed]
The Next Playboy Centerfold Will Be In 3D - playboy 3D - Gizmodo
and 3dcenterfold(s) registered years ago.
Liar?? really? so childish LOL
I have nothing to hide
oh right, my wording was wrong you dropped a link to an external site referring to a playboy mag HAPPY?
Believe it or not, there's literally 100's of thousands upon more thousands of threads in the Ask A Mod section. If you could PM me with the links to your reports (To speed up the process) I'll check them out personally.
Thanks,
Eric Lyon
Member Services