By review do you mean appraisals? There is a thread for that.
I think that the first step in review/appraisal should start with the owner. You may well already be doing this but I would suggest that for each domain you make notes with the following:
List end user categories for this specific domain name.
Sketch out a value proposition for each - if you were in contact with someone from that industry how would you promote why your domain name adds value for them.
I would use NameBio and note comparators for your names, including when and where they sold, as well as for how much.
I would extend the list from (3) by using GoValue that will almost certainly add sales not in NameBio.
I would try to for each domain name see where I would place it in my overall portfolio in two measures: probability of selling and sales price.
Ask yourself, if I had to change my portfolio size which would be the domain name I would first give up and which one would I for sure keep.
(ps one additional thing I find useful is to go through each day's NameBio Daily Sales Report and identify sales that are similar to yours. For example, I have a few domain names involving happy/happiness etc. I note if there have been any sales using Happy and try to see how they are better than my domain name.)
lol .. as much as all the posts above has been informative and helpful .. I think everyone is overcomplicating what you're asking ... you can simply go to this part of the forum to get your domains appraised by other members: