discuss $1,200 offer for AllAboutAutos. com, should I...

it depends how much you acquire

but please edit the domain name because if end user knows it they maybe rethinking

Too low. Yeah, indeed. as per GoDaddy appraisal tool, ("Comparable domains sold" section) this exact domain was once sold for $5,688. Why sell for $1200 today? The same appraisal tool gives Estimated Value: $1,568 for it though, so sending the buyer to this tool makes no sense. You may try to generate a list of comparable domainsales from various sources and send it to the buyer, with sales in low-mid 4 figures range. Asking $4999 and accepting ~$3K - $4K may work - imo. The last but not the least, what you paid for the domain and what is you pricing formula - it is what matters...

Autos is not Auto. In the current market, I believe $1200 is still a reasonable offer for this one. Side note I have quite a bunch of "all about something". Might be worth significantly more if you hold on to it for a few more years.

But you can obviously counter that as you intend to, and see what happens.

Note: Quoting GD appraisals actually tells you're not really in this game

You should be able to repeat same old selling price in my honest opinion. A quick check shows ,allabout-autos. com ,allaboutautos. net and even allaboutautos. co.

Offer installment payment .Don't sell too cheap but, the ball is in your court .
Goodluck .