Dynadot

development UK Nominet in Big Trouble?

Spaceship Spaceship
Watch

premkumar

Top Member
Impact
785
I think many namepros members know that Nominet govern (.uk, co.uk & other uk extensions), yesterday i got mail from them saying "resolution to remove five members of the Nominet Board, including the Chair and the entire executive leadership team."

Literally entire nominet management team may be removed or retained. in case if resolution succeed, they will be removed from their job and i don't know who will govern if that happen and will UK govt take over Nominet administration or remaining members / nominet members elect new chair?


I have few questions:
1. who initiated this resolution? to my knowledge such Extraordinary General Meeting to remove half of board member not done previously.
2. The board promises so many things, if they are retained, some of that they could never listen member request in normal time like:

Freezing .UK prices for at least the next two years
Freezing Board Pay
Investing in .UK infrastructure
Scaling our commitment to Public Benefit
Improving membership engagement
Increasing financial transparency
Launching a Registry Advisory Council (RAC)


Can fellow nominet member in NP, throw some light on what's happening in nominet?


Hey wait i forgot, i got call from nominet today regarding the resolution and asked me to vote, though she said she can't say what to vote but when i said don't worry i will vote No, she laughed more or less it clear they want the resolution to defeated.


I don't know i can share the mail from Nominet, if it can be shared, I will post it .
 
6
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
“The system is rigged if I vote will I change it?”
 
2
•••
@premkumar Thanks. Can you post a link the source of the news?
 
2
•••
5
•••
Actually it turned out to be a coup by some of Nominet members

The entire information can be found in publicbenefit.uk


Look like this coup is supported by nominet founder -Nigel Titley

I just came to know from some other websites, this resolution was initiated by some of big Nominet members ( they need 5% vote for that they got 12%, so resolution is initiated), they were disappointed by UK domain price rise, 70% increase of member salary and reduced donation of public cause and Nominet acquiring a loss making company for $5 million.

They have mentioned about replace them with 2 new members, who will manage the nominet in future.


Look like nominet blatant lie, in their mail, they made it look like nominet in trouble and govt may take control, nothing about who intiated the resolution or reason for the same, just read the below para

"Need to Know: Approval of this resolution would mean serious disruption for our team and endanger the services we provide to you and our other members. It would send a message to government that Nominet is no longer capable of self-governance, and that would put our independence at risk. We need your support to keep Nominet on track. Please vote NO."





The coup initiator not clarifying on few things:

1. Will they reduce the management remuneration, i feel they just maintain the increased compensation.
hope they come clean on it

2. They talk only about 2 member being appointed as replacement chair and Deputy chair, they removing 5 members what about other 3 members? whom they appoint or will they make them also elected member so we can vote and elect them?

3. Main thing they complain is increased domain price and reducing domain price from £3.90 pound but how much will they reduce, will it be back to £2.50 as in 2015 ? Again a silence from them no clarity.

4. since it initiated by top registries, could this be just grabing power from current management team, so they can enjoy power? or will they represent everybody benefit, esp i felt domainers are not represented in nominet decision making.

Last time they released .uk names they gave huge registration connection to nominet server for bigger domain holder like godaddy, so they can register premium names and domainer left with medicore names, i complaint and explained how unfair but they said my complaint is unfounded.

I don't have big vote value but having several thousand names gives me a decent voting right. i plan to get answer from both and vote accordingly. I want them also appoint members from domainers or have a say from us.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
“The system is rigged if I vote will I change it?”

Every vote is counted, if you're a member holding just 1 domain also you get 1332 vote value, it make some difference because not many member cast their vote so your vote will have higher value.

whether you vote for or against resolution, but just excise your right that is very important. Members views and needs will only be taken care only if we vote, otherwise management need to appease only few member who have higher vote value and excise the vote.

I tell you, that's what happening till now and members grievance are not even heard. I felt that many time nobody in nominet taken care of grievance i raised.
 
Last edited:
2
•••
3
•••
wish everything gonna to be ok
 
0
•••
As i live ib the uk etc

.co.uk

And

.uk

Are the uk cctlds and i used to buy .co.uk and .uk but now i dont bother with either cctld as neither are global

I only buy

Gtld

Or

two keyword .com

There are uk domain name auctions which only list

.co.uk and .uk and org.uk etc

But gtlds and two keyword .com are uk domains if they contain english words etc

And there are uk. Domain name resellers that only list or used to

Just

.co.uk

Or

.uk

Etc

But i am so pleased i stopped buying uk cctlds and bought gtlds instead
 
3
•••
wish everything gonna to be ok


sure, but cast your vote

As i live ib the uk etc

.co.uk

And

.uk

Are the uk cctlds and i used to buy .co.uk and .uk but now i dont bother with either cctld as neither are global

I only buy

Gtld

Or

two keyword .com

There are uk domain name auctions which only list

.co.uk and .uk and org.uk etc

But gtlds and two keyword .com are uk domains if they contain english words etc

And there are uk. Domain name resellers that only list or used to

Just

.co.uk

Or

.uk

Etc

But i am so pleased i stopped buying uk cctlds and bought gtlds instead


UK is still a very good market and people sell good number of domains even in 5 figure, you have nominet membership?

My suggestion keep adding uk domains in your portfolio they are good investments but be picky don't buy medicore ones.
 
3
•••
Actually it turned out to be a coup by some of Nominet members

The entire information can be found in publicbenefit.uk


Look like this coup is supported by nominet founder -Nigel Titley

I just came to know from some other websites, this resolution was initiated by some of big Nominet members ( they need 5% vote for that they got 12%, so resolution is initiated), they were disappointed by UK domain price rise, 70% increase of member salary and reduced donation of public cause and Nominet acquiring a loss making company for $5 million.

They have mentioned about replace them with 2 new members, who will manage the nominet in future.


Look like nominet blatant lie, in their mail, they made it look like nominet in trouble and govt may take control, nothing about who intiated the resolution or reason for the same, just read the below para

"Need to Know: Approval of this resolution would mean serious disruption for our team and endanger the services we provide to you and our other members. It would send a message to government that Nominet is no longer capable of self-governance, and that would put our independence at risk. We need your support to keep Nominet on track. Please vote NO."

The coup initiator not clarifying on few things:

1. Will they reduce the management remuneration, i feel they just maintain the increased compensation.
hope they come clean on it

2. They talk only about 2 member being appointed as replacement chair and Deputy chair, they removing 5 members what about other 3 members? whom they appoint or will they make them also elected member so we can vote and elect them?

3. Main thing they complain is increased domain price and reducing domain price from £3.90 pound but how much will they reduce, will it be back to £2.50 as in 2015 ? Again a silence from them no clarity.

4. since it initiated by top registries, could this be just grabing power from current management team, so they can enjoy power? or will they represent everybody benefit, esp i felt domainers are not represented in nominet decision making.

Last time they released .uk names they gave huge registration connection to nominet server for bigger domain holder like godaddy, so they can register premium names and domainer left with medicore names, i complaint and explained how unfair but they said my complaint is unfounded.

I don't have big vote value but having several thousand names gives me a decent voting right. i plan to get answer from both and vote accordingly. I want them also appoint members from domainers or have a say from us.

There is a lot more to this than meets the eye from reading the two documents you mention. The history goes back some way.

The members have been asking questions about the board's change of direction away from members' interests and into their own ambitions for a very long time. You're damned right director's incomes will be cut. Hard. And the remuneration committee done away with altogether for the time being.

The interim board of two people wil be assisted by members to revise the constitution in a direction taking it back to its original purpose of a public interest, membership owned and run, body and a full examination to find the best management structure to do so. Domain pricing of the *.uk stable is a minor issue. More in question is the board's (failed) opportunism in taking on non-.uk TLDs in order to inflate profits (which has failed), whilst simultaneously slashing the amounts awarded to charitable causes and not underpinning the prices of the .uk stable it is supposed to be managing. That UK stable is now underpinning their very costly mistakes in other TLDs and in takeover activities, plus the inner management group's ever inflating "reward" packages. Hence the *.uk price rises.

The stated intention (which I trust, knowing some at least of the instigators) is to return the newly amended constitution to the membership for full consideration, any proposed further amendments by the wider membership and a full membership vote. Hence the limited, two year tenure, proposed for the new incumbents if the motion is passed.
 
Last edited:
7
•••
There is a lot more to this than meets the eye from reading the two documents you mention. The history goes back some way.

The members have been asking questions about the board's change of direction away from members' interests and into their own ambitions for a very long time. You're damned right director's incomes will be cut. Hard. And the remuneration committee done away with altogether for the time being.

The interim board of two people wil be assisted by members to revise the constitution in a direction taking it back to its original purpose of a public interest, membership owned and run, body and a full examination to find the best management structure to do so. Domain pricing of the *.uk stable is a minor issue. More in question is the board's opportunism in taking on non-.uk TLDs in order to inflate profits, whilst simultaneously slashing the amounts awarded to charitable causes and not underpinning the prices of the .uk stable it is supposed to be managing. That UK stable is now underpinning their very costly mistakes in other TLDs and in takeover activities, plus the inner management group's ever inflating "reward" packages. Hence the *.uk price rises.

The stated intention (which I trust, knowing some at least of the instigators) is to return the newly amended constitution to the membership for full consideration, any proposed further amendments by the wider membership and a full membership vote. Hence the limited, two year tenure, proposed for the new incumbents if the motion is passed.


Great thanks for the information. yep moving away from mandate is wrong and also i think, they should make all director positions to be directly elected by members rather than being appointed by few. so that director asking our vote have goals that benefit the nominet and the members. I also like the 2 year tenure, so the director are answerable to their action if they decided to stand for reelection


About price, i have several thousand names and even a pound less per domain save a lot and break even for me.
 
1
•••
I also like the 2 year tenure, so the director are answerable to their action if they decided to stand for reelection

Sorry, I didn't make it quite clear. If the EGM motion is successful, i.e. there are more member votes for it than against, the new interim directors will serve for a period of two years then resign. Full stop. They have already stated they will not stand for re-election.

The structure of the new board or committee of management which will replace them will be designed, with member involvement, over that two year period. It has not yet been decided how long their tenure will be, whether there will a rolling board membership to provide continuity, a whole bunch of questions about how it should be done will be tackled and voted upon, most likely as part of the newly amended constitution.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
1
•••
sure, but cast your vote

the buying and selling of website addresses will be huge in the uk when

uk personalised numberplate resellers

start advertising website addresses in the p apers

which isnt far away as the customer database is the same as those that pay top dollar to buy a personalised licence plate for their uk sportscar etc and the uk personalised numberplate resellers already have outbound sales teams and some of these companies have 40× years experience in this sector etc and these companies wil eventually be able to offer instant purchase for secondhand website addresses which will add liquidity to domain name iinvestors portfolios etc





UK is still a very good market and people sell good number of domains even in 5 figure, you have nominet membership?

My suggestion keep adding uk domains in your portfolio they are good investments but be picky don't buy medicore ones.
 
1
•••
1
•••
Have not received email. Can I vote via my Nominet account?

A cleanup at Nominet is long overdue.
 
2
•••
Have not received email. Can I vote via my Nominet account?

A cleanup at Nominet is long overdue.

It costs over £400 to become a Nominet member, but looks like anyone can join:
https://www.nominet.uk/corporate-governance/members/

Ready to apply?
If you’d like to join Nominet, simply complete our application form and pay a one-off joining fee of £400 (plus VAT). There’s also an annual subscription charge of £100 (plus VAT) if you’d like to continue your membership.

The membership year runs from 1st August to 31st July. If you join after 1st February, your first year’s subscription charge will be reduced to £50 (plus VAT).
 
0
•••
Been bad for years
https://www.theregister.com/2016/09/26/great_british_domain_name_ripoff/

UK domain name holders are being overcharged while the company behind it wins contracts by undercutting the market in what may be illegal market abuse.

In recent months, Nominet has signed a number of back-end contracts with commercial operators of dozens of internet extensions ranging from .boston to .vodka. More deals are in the offing with large corporations like Comcast, and form part of an explicit push by the company's new CEO to take the non-profit organization in a more commercial direction.

However, industry experts are warning that those deals were likely won by Nominet offering below-market rates, effectively using the company's vast profits from the .uk registry to cross-subsidise its commercial ambitions.
 
Last edited:
1
•••
Have not received email. Can I vote via my Nominet account?

A cleanup at Nominet is long overdue.

You should have received an email, I didn't, but I did get a phone call from Nominet asking me if I had received it.

Go to https://secure.cesvotes.com/V3-1-0/nominetEGM21/en/login and click 'Where is my security code?' then click 'Don't know your security code?' and you can enter your Nominet details and you'll get email a link so that you can vote.

(CES are the people that they have conducting the poll btw)
 
Last edited:
2
•••
Last edited:
1
•••
We can all ask .co.uk/.uk registrars to support the changes, which include lower domain renewal prices.

The list of registrars is here: https://registrars.nominet.uk/uk-namespace/registrar-agreement/list-of-registrars/

Is this supported by @GoDaddy @Paul Nicks @Joe Styler ?

And Uniregistry are on that members list, so are @namesilo @Dynadot @namecheap @Internet.bs - do they support the changes too?
I take it that you voted yes then?

Check https://publicbenefit.uk for a pretty decent list of supporters.
 
Last edited:
1
•••
I take it that you voted yes then?

Check https://publicbenefit.uk for a pretty decent list of supporters.

https://publicbenefit.uk/#support


Hi thanks, we need to lobby the undecided companies on that list - Godaddy, Namecheap, 1&1/Ionos, TuCows, Key-Systems, Markmonitor...

13 of Top 20 Undecided

Rank Name Domains Votes
#1
GoDaddy.com (123-reg, Heart, TSOHost, Daily, Domain Monster) 3,642,290 207,973
#2
1&1 Ionos (Ionos, Fasthosts) 1,696,701 207,973
#3
Namesco (LCN) 612,238 207,973
#4
TUCOWS (OpenSRS, Enom) 381,468 207,973
#5
PDR (Web.com, Arvixe, HostGator, Bluehost, iPage, A Small Orange, JustHost, Site 5, NetworkSolutions) 333,305 207,973
#6
Corporation Service Company (UK) 243,202 207,973
#7
Namecheap 201,355 202,686
#8
Iomart Hosting (Easyspace, Bytemark, Memset) 145,213 146,544
#9
Key-Systems (CentralNic, InternetBS) 134,040 135,371
#10
UK2 132,495 133,826
#13
One.com 89,021 90,352
#17
Markmonitor 44,723 46,054
#19
OVH 35,352 36,683

Not a member so can't vote, only ask registrars to vote.
 
Last edited:
1
•••
I think Godaddy undecided. I don't know why namecheap not decided yet, UK is their main market, hope they make a decision soon.

if 13 of top 20 (not decided yet) decide to vote No, then its approx 29% vote, on the other hand the publicbenefit.uk gather 20.8% till today. Its going to be interesting to see how many of this will be successfully persuade by current Nominet team. So still, it just handful of registrar going to decide the fate of this resolution?

Also publicbenefit may not have all the members who decided to vote YES but not given their name in publicbenefit.uk, so the YES vote may have higher percentage than those 20.8%.

Its important Godaddy, Namecheap, Namesilo, dynadot registrars should clear their stand on resolution before voting complete, so we domainer know whether our domains are in rightful hands.
 
Last edited:
0
•••
More info this week:

https://www.theregister.com/2021/03/02/nominet_board_vote/

re Nominet CEO Russell Haworth that article says that:

An online search will also reveal that Haworth and his executive team have been accused of paying themselves double-digit pay rises while increasing the price of .uk domains, slashing the money that goes to charitable causes, overseeing a drop in operating profit, and embarking on a series of failed commercial efforts in unrelated markets including autonomous vehicles, the internet of things and white space spectrum management.
 
Last edited:
3
•••
Back