Why .CA registry took back my name?

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Hi ,guys yestoday i regged Bentley.ca and took back by registry today without any emails when i checked my account

Whats wrong in the world with .CA registry?

beraking my heart

only refund but no any compensations? sucks!

Could i file a law suit against .CA registry?

any good advice will be much appreciat it!

MasterOfMyDomains · Feb 18, 2019

missed that, my apology. It was due to it being a geographic name.

Now i read, you posted that info after i posted. Also you say you are checking your email box

VaneZhao said:
Im extremely angry with the CAregistry and so sad for Namesilo services because both they didnt sent even an email to my mailbox before took back my domain

Why your box and not your friends? Sounds fishy, I'd like proof it was reg in your friends name or I am calling bullshit on this one

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
I told my friend that name is available,and My friend regged it ,she is Chinese- Canadian,doing business in Canada

Right, but it wasn't available as you found out later. There is a reason it was stuck in pendingcreate. It was not actually available.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

MasterOfMyDomains said:
missed that, my apology. It was due to it being a geographic name.

Now i read, you posted that info after i posted. Also you say you are checking your email box

Why your box and not your friends? Sounds fishy, I'd like proof it was reg in your friends name or I am calling bullsh*t on this one

cause my mailbox is mine and my mailbox is my friend too,make sense?

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
Right, but it wasn't available as you found out later. There is a reason it was stuck in pendingcreate. It was not actually available.

Brad

We should put like this way,Its totally .CA registry fault,if they reserved then we or anyone cant have the desire or chance to reg it,just like Adult.xxx,i used to reg this name and took back by the registry as well,but they sent me an email first,then took back that name ,and finally ,i got rebursements from them also not reg fees,here is another example,once a Chinese domainer regged F Uck.hk and took back by HK registry and paid10000 USD rebursements by HK registry,so .CA registry should have done some rebursements as well,why?RESPECT, They should pay for their fault

JordanH · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
We should put like this way,Its totally .CA registry fault

No put it this way. It is 100% your fault for trying to register a .CA domain if you are not Canadian. Regardless if the domain was reserved or not.

You agree to these terms when trying to register it.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

JordanH said:
No put it this way. It is 100% your fault for trying to register a .CA domain if you are not Canadian. Regardless if the domain was reserved or not.

You agree to these terms when trying to register it.

Here is another illiteracy，arent you ? I have said in my thread before that i found that name is available for registration ,then i did screenshot to my friend,a Chinese-canadian ,doing business in Canada, she has the right to reg that name,am i against .CA registry rules?

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

We should put like this way,Its totally .CA registry fault,if they reserved then we or anyone cant have the desire or chance to reg it,just like Adult.xxx,i used to reg this name and took back by the registry as well,but they sent me an email first,then took back that name ,and finally ,i got rebursements from them also not reg fees,here is another example,once a Chinese domainer regged F Uck.hk and took back by HK registry and paid10000 USD rebursements by HK registry,so .CA registry should have done some rebursements as well,why?RESPECT, They should pay for their fault

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

.CA registry and FR registry are both ROBBERIES ,because they tend to took back registered domains without any email to the owners,be aware of them!

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

Typing in big red font doesn't make what you are saying any more credible or compelling.

Brad

carob · Feb 18, 2019

Eventually almost all of us have the experience of registering a name, then not getting it - for various reasons, such as registrar mistake, reserved name, price error.

I registered a beautiful cannabis name in another country code at another registrar, got the confirmation email, then a few minutes later a refund email, with no explanation.

When I looked at the terms and conditions website for that country code, I found a list of reserved terms and my word was on it. Too bad for me. Yes I wish I had not been able to try to register it, but nobody else can either. People often are wrongly told .uk domains are available when in fact they may be reserved for the .co.uk owner, or affected by residence conditions.

If you think a mistake has happened, it is usually best to investigate before calling it a crime scene.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
Typing in big red font doesn't make what you are saying any more credible or compelling.

Brad

CIRA Registration Services <[email protected]> and [email protected] Has sent
Hello cira,
Why the domain Bentley.ca took back without even an email noticed?
what does RESPECT stand for according to your understanding?

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

CIRA Registration Services <[email protected]> and [email protected] Has sent
Hello cira,
Why the domain Bentley.ca took back without even an email noticed?
what does RESPECT stand for according to your understanding?

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

I think you should appreciate the people that posted in this thread taking their valuable time to explain the situation to you. The domain was not available. The domain was never registered to you.

You are not going to get the domain. You are not going to to get compensation. You are not going to sue them. Move on.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

carob said:
Eventually almost all of us have the experience of registering a name, then not getting it - for various reasons, such as registrar mistake, reserved name, price error.

I registered a beautiful cannabis name in another country code at another registrar, got the confirmation email, then a few minutes later a refund email, with no explanation.

When I looked at the terms and conditions website for that country code, I found a list of reserved terms and my word was on it. Too bad for me. Yes I wish I had not been able to try to register it, but nobody else can either. People often are wrongly told .uk domains are available when in fact they may be reserved for the .co.uk owner, or affected by residence conditions.

If you think a mistake has happened, it is usually best to investigate before calling it a crime scene.

Hello,firstly, sorry to hear that ,but i should say im so lucky because i registered so many CO.UK domains and never be token back,
as you know,domains were propertes online ,let me put this way ,domains are MONEY,no one hates money ,therefore,some registries and registars are become Greedy for their own benefits by means of all means ,escepically,these rules set by them when you begin to reg a domain,to some extend,why are they so rampant ?the answer is so simple ,thats, domainers always give up on their own legal right to protect their own interests,if domainers join hands to file law suit against these greddy and rampant as well as untrusted registies or registars always, then they will be behavor in the furture!

carob · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
if domainers join hands to file law suit against these greddy and rampant as well as untrusted registies or registars always, then they will be behavor in the furture!

If domainers read and respect the terms and conditions of registrars and registries they can save a lot of time and aggravation. A registrar is not obliged to take your business - they can ask you to move all your domains to another registrar or face cancellation. It happens - I have seen angry threads by customers fired by registrars.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
I think you should appreciate the people that posted in this thread taking their valuable time to explain the situation to you. The domain was not available. The domain was never registered to you.

You are not going to get the domain. You are not going to to get compensation. You are not going to sue them. Move on.

Brad

why are they so rampant ?the answer is so simple ,thats, domainers always give up on their own legal right to protect their own interests,if domainers join hands to file law suit against these greddy and rampant as well as untrusted registies or registars always, then they will be behavor in the furture!

Im turning to laywers for help now

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Hello,firstly, sorry to hear that ,but i should say im so lucky because i registered so many CO.UK domains and never be took back,
as you know,domains were propertes online ,let me put this way ,domains are MONEY,no one hates money ,therefore,some registries and registars are become Greedy for their own benefits by means of all means ,escepically,these rules set by them when you begin to reg a domain,to some extend,why are they so rampant ?the answer is so simple ,thats, domainers always give up on their own legal right to protect their own interests,if domainers join hands to file law suit against these greddy and rampant as well as untrusted registies or registars always, then they will be behavor in the furture!

No. Once again the domain was not available. It was not actually registered to you.
There might have been a glitch where it appeared available, but it actually wasn't. Mistakes happen.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

carob said:
If domainers read and respect the terms and conditions of registrars and registries they can save a lot of time and aggravation. A registrar is not obliged to take your business - they can ask you to move all your domains to another registrar or face cancellation. It happens - I have seen angry threads by customers fired by registrars.

If i were that domainers ,nothing can stand in my way to protect my own interests!
Have you ever thought of why are they so rampant ?the answer is so simple ,thats, domainers always give up on their own legal right to protect their own interests,if domainers join hands to file law suit against these greddy and rampant as well as untrusted registies or registars always, then they will be behavor in the furture!

carob · Feb 18, 2019

Unsubscribing from this repetitive thread, sometimes trying to help is a waste of time.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
No. Once again the domain was not available. It was not actually registered to you.
There might have been a glitch where it appeared available, but it actually wasn't. Mistakes happen.

Brad

the domain state displayed OK after i registered and i did screenshot and saved it,today my domain has gone

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

carob said:
Unsubscribing from this repetitive thread, sometimes trying to help is a waste of time.

Chinese people tend to respect others and forgive those who show rude and illiteracy ，thats one of reason why China has become more and more powerful and influencial country in the world!

Start · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
I am guessing it is related to this city - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bentley,_Alberta

Probably .ab.ca

Brad

Brad already gave you the answer, but you don't seem to want to listen to him or anyone else.

Bentley.ca is reserved for the Town of Bentley - they currently use www.townofbentley.ca , but they have the rights to bentley.ca as well.

If Bentley.ca was actually truly registerable, this big Canadian luggage store chain: ShopBentley.com would have registered it long ago, or the car company could have as well.

You will only waste your time and money if you complain about this. You don't own a .ca until CIRA approves it. And they won't approve Bentley.ca, because it's reserved for a Canadian town.

You don't have any legal rights to the name, and you never did. Even actual Canadians couldn't have legal rights to it, only the Town of Bentley does.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Start said:
Brad already gave you the answer, but you don't seem to want to listen to him or anyone else.

Bentley.ca is reserved for the Town of Bentley - they currently use www.townofbentley.ca , but they have the rights to bentley.ca as well.

If Bentley.ca was actually truly registerable, this big Canadian luggage store chain: ShopBentley.com would have registered it long ago, or the car company could have as well.

You will only waste your time and money if you complain about this. You don't own a .ca until CIRA approves it. And they won't approve Bentley.ca, because it's reserved for a Canadian town.

Its totally .CA registry fault,if they reserved ,then nothing happens,right?

Start · Feb 18, 2019

CIRA has an approval process for domains, and yours doesn't qualify.

.ca works differently than .com.

Also, CIRA support staff don't work on weekends (and I doubt any others do either), and you said you only registered it yesterday. They will probably email you this week anyway.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Start said:
CIRA has an approval process for domains, and yours doesn't qualify.

.ca works differently than .com.

Also, CIRA staff don't work on weekends, and you said you only registered it yesterday. They will probably email you this week anyway.

that doesnt make sense ,because,if they are not on work ,but how to refund ?i have recived my reg fess and I dont recive emails both from Registar namesilo and .CA registry noticed

Why .CA registry took back my name?

domaining story-tellerTop Member

WVWTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Established Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

Top Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Top Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Top Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Established Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Established Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Similar threads

We're social

Pinned

Appreciation

Agreement