Why .CA registry took back my name?

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Hi ,guys yestoday i regged Bentley.ca and took back by registry today without any emails when i checked my account

Whats wrong in the world with .CA registry?

beraking my heart

only refund but no any compensations? sucks!

Could i file a law suit against .CA registry?

any good advice will be much appreciat it!

wwwweb · Feb 18, 2019

pending create means there is a sub domain that has reservation rights over this name. ie) bentely.on.ca or something etc...

Stop trying to game the system, .ca is not like .com, you need to understand what you are doing, you just can't do whatever you like.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Hello Namesilo,

The.CA registry didnt contacted me and even a mail sent by them,

I found this domain has gone when i check my account,after that i checked my mailbox immediately

and there was no email sent by registry and your company,to tell the turth,i was so disappointed about your services and mad at CA registry as well

Im thinking if i should file law suit against .CA registry!

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

wwwweb said:
pending create means there is a sub domain that has reservation rights over this name. ie) bentely.on.ca or something etc...

Stop trying to game the system, .ca is not like .com, you need to understand what you are doing, you just can't do whatever you like.

I am guessing it is related to this city - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bentley,_Alberta

Probably .ab.ca

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Hi,

please check your mailboxes as .ca registry may have contacted you multiple times regarding this domain.

We can't activate this domain for you, please contact https://cira.ca/ for help.

Please let us know if there is anything else we can help with!

Thank you for being a customer at NameSilo!

NameSilo Support Team

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Hi,

please check your mailboxes as .ca registry may have contacted you multiple times regarding this domain.

We can't activate this domain for you, please contact https://cira.ca/ for help.

Please let us know if there is anything else we can help with!

Thank you for being a customer at NameSilo!

NameSilo Support Team

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Hello Namesilo,

The.CA registry didnt contacted me and even a mail sent by them,

I found this domain has gone when i check my account,after that i checked my mailbox immediately

and there was no email sent by registry and your company,to tell the turth,i was so disappointed about your services and mad at CA registry as well

Im thinking if i should file law suit against .CA registry!

That makes no sense. You are going to spend tens of thousands on a lawsuit to try to claim a domain that was never actually registered? I would suggest just moving on.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
I am guessing it is related to this city - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bentley,_Alberta

Probably .ab.ca

Brad

Make no sense,I was told Bentley is common last name and first name in Canada,

creataweb · Feb 18, 2019

Try another name maybe?

Screen Shot 2019-02-18 at 1.50.59 AM.png

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Make no sense,I was told Bentley is common last name and first name in Canada,

That is not relevant if the domain was not available to register in the first place.

It is rather hard to believe that the term "Bentley" would just be sitting there for decades waiting for someone to register it, if available.

The explanation given above makes sense. It is likely reserved, therefore it is stuck in pendingcreate.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

creataweb said:
Try another name maybe?Show attachment 110127

Im extremely angry with the CAregistry and so sad for Namesilo services because both they didnt sent even an email to my mailbox before took back my domain

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Im extremely angry with the CAregistry and so sad for Namesilo services because both they didnt sent even an email to my mailbox before took back my domain

Well, it is not your domain. It was never created and then the registry put it on server hold.

The communication might be less than desired, but it is pretty clear the domain was not actually available to register. I am not sure if the issue was with NameSilo or the .CA registry itself.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
That is not relevant if the domain was not available to register in the first place.

It is rather hard to believe that the term "Bentley" would just be sitting there for decades waiting for someone to register it, if available.

The explanation given above makes sense. It is likely reserved, therefore it is stuck in pendingcreate.

Brad

NO any emails contacted before took it back ？NO any compensations，Once a Chinese domainer regged FUCK.HK and took back by HK registry and pay the owner 10000USD

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
NO any emails contacted before took it back ？NO any compensations，Once a Chinese domainer regged f Uck.HK and took back by HK registry and pay the owner 10000USD

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

Once a Chinese domainer regged f Uck.HK and took back by HK registry and pay the owner 10000USD

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
Well, it is not your domain. It was never created and then the registry put it on server hold.

The communication might be less than desired, but it is pretty clear the domain was not actually available to register. I am not sure if the issue was with NameSilo or the .CA registry itself.

Brad

Thats why im thinking if i should file a law suit against CAregistry or Namesilo, to be frank,im experienced in dealing with such a case cause i have filed several registries in the past,and i used to ask for domain king,
Rick Schwartz for help!

bmugford · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Thats why im thinking if i should file a law suit against CAregistry or Namesilo, to be frank,im experienced in dealing with such a case cause i have filed several registries in the past,and i used to ask for domain king,
Rick Schwartz for help!

Good luck with that.

Brad

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

bmugford said:
Good luck with that.

Brad

Thanks!

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

wwwweb said:
pending create means there is a sub domain that has reservation rights over this name. ie) bentely.on.ca or something etc...

Stop trying to game the system, .ca is not like .com, you need to understand what you are doing, you just can't do whatever you like.

You can tolerate about .CA registry such robbery behavor? if they sent me an email and then told the details ,i may give up ,but they not,if everybody whose registered domains took back by .CA registry and filed law suit against them ,they wont next time，otherwise，They are more rampant all the time

gilescoley · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
Thats why im thinking if i should file a law suit against CAregistry or Namesilo, to be frank,im experienced in dealing with such a case cause i have filed several registries in the past,and i used to ask for domain king,
Rick Schwartz for help!

You cant take them to court, the domain was never yours.

Take this is as a learning experience, cut your losses and move on. You know you arent going to spend 5K or $10k on a lawsuit on a non-premium .ca domain. We see people every week threatening lawsuit against registrars but this never happens. Rick Schwartz wont and cant do anything about this either.

JordanH · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
has refund but without any email,.CA registry is robbery

Not really. As a Canadian citizen, I agree. You shouldn't be allowed to register .ca domains. Your "loophole" is irrelevant. because you are not a Canadian citizen, you do not get to own .ca domains.

MasterOfMyDomains · Feb 18, 2019

you'll get reimbursed, stop whining. @namesilo you seem to be letting non canadian entities reg .ca
not cool. And Vane you started a thread about your desire for a .ca and people told you the requirements, now we know what it is.
You kind of disgust me, there are rules, you knew them, follow them.
Give him/her their money back @namesilo so they can shut up

wwwweb · Feb 18, 2019

VaneZhao said:
You can tolerate about .CA registry such robbery behavor? if they sent me an email and then told the details ,i may give up ,but they not,if everybody whose registered domains took back by .CA registry and filed law suit against them ,they wont next time，otherwise，They are more rampant all the time

As Brad pointed out Bentley AB is probably why the block is in place. Why don't you read the TOS of the .CA registry you will see all domains like city.ca town.ca village.ca are all reserved as the registry does not want any outside confusion.

It is clear you are trying to register while on location in China, in violation of the registry residency rules. Move on, why are you obsessed, otherwise call your lawyers, and pay your retainers, and we will see where you land very quickly.

You are not listening, you are not allowed to register this name, it doesn't matter if your brothers friend likes the car, doesn't give you a higher authority to register the domain.

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

JordanH said:
Not really. As a Canadian citizen, I agree. You shouldn't be allowed to register .ca domains. Your "loophole" is irrelevant. because you are not a Canadian citizen, you do not get to own .ca domains.

I told my friend that name is available,and My friend regged it ,she is Chinese- Canadian,doing business in Canada

MasterOfMyDomains · Feb 18, 2019

File one of these

https://imgur.com/9l2gdWA

domainnews · Feb 18, 2019

MasterOfMyDomains said:
you'll get reimbursed, stop whining. @namesilo you seem to be letting non canadian entities reg .ca
not cool. And Vane you started a thread about your desire for a .ca and people told you the requirements, now we know what it is.
You kind of disgust me, there are rules, you knew them, follow them.
Give him/her their money back @namesilo so they can shut up

Hi,are you illiteracy?I told my friend that name is available,and My friend regged it ,she is Chinese- Canadian,doing business in Canada

Why .CA registry took back my name?

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Top Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Some Guy with Awesome Senior High School PhotoTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

www.DataCube.comTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Top Member

Established Member

WVWTop Member

Top Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

WVWTop Member

domaining story-tellerTop Member

Similar threads

We're social

Pinned

Appreciation

Agreement