offers $250 offer for Callisto dot co - Shall I take it?

Nice name. This is the type of .co domains that sell well. I would definitely counter. GL.

A nice name with mythical, astronomical, as well as peope and place name significance. You probably already searched this but the .com sold for $69,500 a number of years ago but sits unused with a GoDaddy parking page. It may represent competition. I presume you plan a higher counter which I would, but I don't feel qualified to suggest a figure. Best wishes for it.
Bob

You should counter it I think you will get a better offer.

Counter

Thanks you for all the responses, I'll counter. Which approach should I choose? Ask an exact amount or a range (e.g. low four figure)? I think the maximum amount I'd go for is $1,xxx.

Specify your price.

@kaposzta it depends on your personal circumstances and how much you need the cash.

If you need the sale, go low around $1500. If you're willing to push the boat out a bit further, go for $5000 and see what they come back with, but be prepared to lose the sale.

Based on a quick bit of research (and my own circumstances), I think this is an easy $3k-4k domain.

You should also set up a landing page - looks like it doesn't resolve at the moment (403 error)

Good luck

I think you need exact counter price on domainagents. there are no ranges there.

usually you want to counter first offer.. if you go too high you will lose buyer. I lost a few on domainagents.. and elsehwere.. countering .co names in 4 figures.... including recent $200 offr on DA for delivr(.co)... countered 4 figures.. and then kept lowering .. even all the way to his $200.. but never heard a word from him

gl

I would certainly counter at around 1.5k , It's a nice Spanish sounding name and the lettering looks good, No harm in pointing out the .com sale and price (just leave the date blank) in your response.

I'm not a great fan of the .Co domain. But, I've got to admit people are using them, and in particular the younger Yanks

It depend.. if you hold the name for long time and you never get an offer then counter low.. if you get frequent offers then counter high.

I've sold a few $xxxx .co now. This one isn't bad .. but not as strong as the ones I'm used to. The good thing you have going for you however, is that it's a very specific name (either their name or the name of their exisiting company) and if they are indeed a serious inquiry, then chances are they are limited on the alternatives.

Personally I would do a first counter in the 2 and even 3k range just to be sure not to leave anything on the table .. but I wouldn't say no to anything above $1k and I'd likely even go further down than that as it's too specific a name and likely not getting serious offers very regularly. That being said .. at $200-250 you'll find yourself big time in the red overall as maintaining a .co portfolio isn't as cheap as one in .com.