I came to suggest an auction form idea I had, similar to what
@silentg posted
BASIC IDEA
I'm not suggesting make a new auction platform like Sedo etc, the forums and thread setup would still be used. Just something extra
added to it.
When creating an auction you are presented with some choices - auction for "single domain name", "multi domain names" (as the forms would differ). You are then presented with a form to fill in with various things.
Some elements will be read only, not edited later, mandatory, optional, etc.
We should definitely still have the normal (as is now) text area for posting as not every eventuality can be thought of and catered in a form. And people can still write other things eg "10 years old" etc.
After it's all submitted, this new form data/auction info could be displayed inbetween the thread title and the top post in the thread. This would make it official looking, like it's actually auction info and not just a forum post
I suggest this has a marketplace forum of it's own, so that there is no "create new thread" button just "Create Auction" button, so people cannot bypass using the form. Any created in some other forum be quickly identified, reported, and closed.
FORM FOR STARTING AN AUCTION
I think we'd need two options for "single name" "multiple names". There'd be different fields, such as single name auction could provide expiry date, whereas multi auction (ie 60 names) probs not. The normal thread text area would cater for that.
Example form input fields for single name auction:
- Domain Name
- TLD (not sure if useful separate. Could provide nice stats about what TLDs are selling etc)
- Expiry
- Registrar
- Starting bid
- Min Increments
- BIN (can leave blank, or enter either numeric value or "TBA")
- DROP DOWN: Auction ends after (hours) || Auction ends in (hours) || etc, THEN enter hour value (eg 72 hours)
- Etc
(We all know a BIN ends the auction immediately, no need to state this)
Some could be optional.
The form fields for a multi domain name auction would need some thought. For example "Domain Names" field could be a text box area and can enter names separated by comma, new line, etc.
Option to choose if individual domains, or lot sale.
Etc
FORM FOR PLACING "BIDS"
I also suggest a form input for placing bids.
So when user clicks new button "Bid", using the new form data from the auction the bidder could be presented with:
- The input field to enter their bid
- The current highest bid (or "none")
- The increment required
- The next lowest possible valid bid based on last highest bid and increment (or if no bids the start bid)
For people who choose to ignore this new field and just use the form post text area, their bid won't be counted. The auction data will show "Highest bid $10 by USERNAME" and that won't be them.
A new rule can be added to reflect this "Bids placed outside the official bid input are invalid". The next bidder will just be shown the previous
valid bid.
Also, if a user has not used the bid form, then their post can be labelled "This is not a bid". So essentially the site will manage and show valid and invalid bids, the highest bid, the next lowest bid possible, and this will reduce staff intervention too!
Bidders can still post with a normal reply text area as currently, eg to ask for clarification, etc (it is still a forum platform).
USER SETTINGS FOR DISPLAY
Not sure if too much overhead, but being able to choose how we see the auctions would be great. Such as order of the fields displayed "domain name first, then registrar, then ....etc".
This would be in main user settings in profile area "Auction thread view".
ADVANTAGES
Mandatory fields will ensure people provide the bare minimum and only change things they can, as per the rules (eg BIN) (they could just post in the normal thread text area, but people abuse that now, so this
doesn't introduce a problem).
With this suggestion, auctions could have:
- The same layout for important information
- No important information missing
- No confusion or uncertainty about an auction's details
- The domain name being in a field can be passed through validation to determine if it's IDN, what the chars are exactly (and the site could even list the name in lower and upper case)
- The auction details can be listed at the top of every page in that thread (no more going pointlessly back to page 1)
- The current highest bid can be displayed by the site scripts, at the top of the thread, in the title, etc
- More info can be given in alerts, instead of "Username replied to this thread" it could have "Username bid $XX in ThreadName, your highest bid was $xx"
STATS:
The data stored like this (rather than text field) means stats and other functionality can be provided based on each auction form field and bid.
BIDDING:
The info gathered by the auction form can be presented to a bidder, save scrolling up and down etc. Just click "bid" and you see "increments", "highest bid" etc.
When a user tries to enter an invalid bid - too low from required increments or below the previous bid, etc - the form will return an error and not post, so no invalid bids will be placed!
OTHER:
There are likely all kinds of useful things that could come from this. Stats such as "average sold price on Namepros" "highest bid ever" etc etc (these might not be useful or welcomed, but are just examples).
Mandatory fields on auction forms would reduce the amount of reports on auctions, and thus less staff time.
_____________________________________________________
I totally get this would be a huge huge change, it's just an idea, as there are many auctions in Namepros, and handling all aspects with a forum platform is not always ideal