Thanks for your help Yanosh and 411domains. I ended up reaching out to a rep through the Dan chat and gave my list of names to them, they fixed it right away. :)
In my portfolio, I have some of my listings that say "Active Listing" and others that say "already listed on Afternic."
What's the best way to resolve this. I do have an afternic account but am not thrilled about going through all of my domains...