Dynadot

advice Why Should You Use an ICANN Accredited Registrar?

NameSilo
This may not be something that you've thought about before, but is the domain name registrar that you use ICANN accredited? Naturally, the majority of registrars around the World are accredited, because it is required to register gTLD names, but there are instances of registrars that are not ICANN accredited. If you have domain names with these registrars, your names may not be as safe.

I've been researching this topic for quite a while, and I think that it's important to share this information around. I believe that ICANN accreditation is a must for any domain registrar and should be a factor in which registrar you choose, even when choosing a registrar to register your country-code (ccTLD) names.

icann.jpg
ICANN is the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers. More details can be found about ICANN on their Wikipedia page, but in short, they control and maintain the domain name system that allows the Internet to operate as it does.

Accreditation indicates that a domain name registrar operates in a certain way, with certain restrictions and guarantees as defined and enforced by ICANN, which helps to protect domain name owners. Each registrar that wants to be accredited with ICANN needs to submit a non-refundable $3,500 application fee and must show ICANN that they are capable of operating the registrar effectively.

There are many more criteria that these registrars must follow, which can be viewed on ICANN's website, but essentially each registrar needs to comply to strict guidelines concerning capital, security, and system assurances; otherwise, their accredited status may be lost. This has happened many times before, with one famous case being that of RegisterFly.

Is your domain name registrar ICANN accredited? You can check the current list at ICANN's website.

ICANN are extremely vigilant in monitoring domain registrars to ensure they keep to the Registrar Accreditation Agreement. However, ICANN accreditation does not mean that your domains are safe against hacking or theft, but it does mean that should anything happen to the registrar where your domains reside, such as the registrar going out of business, you are protected and will not lose your gTLD domains.

ICANN accreditation is often overlooked in the choosing of a domain registrar, and I think that it is something that is somewhat taken for granted.
 
11
•••
The views expressed on this page by users and staff are their own, not those of NamePros.
A very valuable heads up!
 
0
•••
I was not aware that there were any that were not accredited, other then resellers of accredited registrars. Which ones are non-accredited registrars?
 
1
•••
Your article doesn't make sense. It's *impossible* to register a gTLD domain name with a non ICANN accredited registrar. I'll see that again; *impossible*. So the remainder of your article is moot.

Many ICANN accredited registrars have resellers. I'm a reseller of some although I don't resell to all and sundry. Even resellers are beholden to ICANN accredited registrars, merely a tier underneath. The gTLD is ultimately registered with a ICANN accredited registrar even if it's through the reseller of one.

ccTLD's are different and have nothing to do with ICANN so many people register those through registrars that aren't also ICANN accredited because that accreditation has absolutely no bearing on any ccTLD. In respect of *.uk domain names the registry is Nominet and the company has many Nominet registrars that sell *.uk domain names, some have resellers too.

Please refrain from writing about something until you are informed about it. :)
 
2
•••
http://publicdomainregistry.com/partners/ - this is their reseller page "partners include ResellerClub and Bigrock".
And then there are others like ELB group, who also has resellers. They just make a little off the top when a reseller sells a name, and it renews, and sometimes they renew a dropping name for themselves. Here is an example of an offer to become a reseller: http://urpage.partnersite.myorderbox.com/. In this company, called ELB group, you would pay 100 up front, and then sell names through a self-branded reseller page. Nothing nefarious about it, all gTLDs are registered through an ICANN accredited registrar. You can look at the whois for this name (my client's) to see who the registrar is. All of them have that field to show who the actual registrar is that it is registered through.

I5f0j9V.png
 
0
•••
Yes, all resellers resell through ICANN accredited registrars. But I think that the main point, is that if you register your domains with an ICANN accredited registrar, things go much faster. Let's imagine that you need to transfer your domain name out and you need an EPP code. If your name is with reseller, you may run into the issue, when that reseller is not responsive. So to get the EPP you'll need to contact their upstream provider, who most likely won't be able to help you right away, because your name is not directly with them. So you lose time, which may result (for example, if you sold your domain to someone) into not closed deal.

I'm not saying that it is the case with every reseller, just saying that one can run into trouble with some of them.
 
0
•••
It is also important to note that some Icann-accredited registrars can also be resellers for some extensions they do not carry themselves, like ccTLDs. Moniker is an example unless that has changed, they were using Domain24 for ccTLDs if I remember correctly.

The problem with resellers is that they often are a one-man show. If they die or disappear you are in trouble and you'll have to sort out the situation with the upstream registrar if they are even willing to help.
Same problem when only the 'webmaster' has access to the domain name, and goes awol. If he registered the domain in his name you are screwed.

Bottom line: register with accredited registrars only, and do not delegate registration and control to a 'webmaster' who is not an in-house employee.
 
3
•••
It is also important to note that some Icann-accredited registrars can also be resellers for some extensions they do not carry themselves, like ccTLDs. Moniker is an example unless that has changed, they were using Domain24 for ccTLDs if I remember correctly.
.

I had similar issue with eNom. I needed to change the contact info on .es domain. I contacted them and they sent me to the registry to make the changes, registry sent me to 1API (who is the actual registrar of the domain) and 1API sent me to.. wait for it... eNom! And finally eNom made the change. I lost about 2 weeks to make that change.
 
0
•••
.es is tricky: for a change of owner both buyer and seller have to send a form (in Spanish) + copy of ID to the registry. At least that was the procedure back then.
I would check the whois just to be sure you really own the domain.
 
1
•••
Informative. Thanks for sharing
 
0
•••
Very Valuable Information! Thanks :)
 
0
•••
  • The sidebar remains visible by scrolling at a speed relative to the page’s height.
Back