ALG

I am starting to get more serious on my domaining and I had a logo created for my site. I would love to get some feedback..
????: NamePros.com http://www.namepros.com/graphic-design-flash/518601-what-logo-do-you-like-best.html

So how can you help? Pick 1, 2, or 3 and then let me know what you think would go with it.

For those who actually give me a heartfelt explanation, I won't turn away from giving you some NP cash for your time.


OPTION 1

OPTION 2

OPTION 3

Thank you!

bobbie

All three of them are the same. Looks good but they are the same

Bodhi

My powers of observation may be a bit off, but all three look the same to me. It is a nice looking logo though. It might be just a tad bit too busy for the final site, but I would have to see the site. When I click on your site link I am only seeing the default index.

ALG

Yes they are all the same, I am trying to figure whether I should go with a dark, clear or off color background or if the scheme looks good. The site isnt there yet because I want it to be centered around the logo scheme

evtimii

The links points to one and the same logo:

http://i335.photobucket.com/albums/m.../logoblack.jpg

but...

what I do and what I do not like in my opinion:

the star is a little bit unnecessary or could be changed with a better star

the text is a little bit hidden behind all objects
????: NamePros.com http://www.namepros.com/showthread.php?t=518601

the 4 "light reflections" are too powerful



I really like

the text coloring

the back arcs

dark background is more better than light background, because the used colors will "hide" in a white or transparent background

I'm waiting for my np$'s

__________________
<; VqqX.com
<; Logo design

Bodhi

The logo background depends on the site. I think a dark header with the logo would look good with a white (or lighter) center panel beneath the header and darker background on the sides. That way you draw the user's eyes to the content of your site.
????: NamePros.com http://www.namepros.com/showthread.php?t=518601

(no NP needed here, best of luck with the site!)

notlikeyou

The three tone letters to me scream 1970's (not sure if that was the look you were going for). I would almost like to see the color blend/fade into the next without the set. Or made it a 2 color step. The arc that cover's the "R" in star is a bit distracting, it covers an integral line that defines the "R". The star is a bit big & just ok. The logo is just OK in my book it's lacking that something that makes it POP. Almost needs another color.

You can keeps the NP$, best of luck with the site.

__________________
DriverSalary.com
PopularAppetizers.com

need a LLLL.com make an offer

Hurley4540

It's all the same link I believe....

upbeat

I think there's a slight problem with using the word domain(s) twice within the logo. Instead of saying Shine Brighter than any Domain - Starpower Domains, I would go with something like, Light up the Internet - Starpower Domains, or along those lines. The artistry is attractive.

gaucho1976

first of all, resize your logo to the actual size you're going to use it. ie, I resized it to 120px width (for buttons) and ended with something barely better than a blur.

Now, ask yourself a question: what are you selling? what are you trying to stick in surfer's minds? what kind of visual element are you looking for to stick on people? are you selling glowing curves?
????: NamePros.com http://www.namepros.com/showthread.php?t=518601

IMHO, the answer is: 1) domains 2) Starpower domains 3) star, starpower, domains word 4) no

this being said, take off all those curves and glows, they don't add anything and causes a lot of "visual noise", specially on resizing. The colors looks good, but I'd go with 2 steps gradient instead of 3. take the "shine brighter.... " wording unless you're using that size for the logo, which I doubt. Thy the star and the words with plain color variations, less 3Dish stuff and see which one looks better at different sizes. And finally, the bullet proof test: convert to grayscale and see how it looks. Adjust it as needed (it needs adjust, I tried it)

hope that helps, no NP needed, I don't even know what it is or how to use it, lol

useless

the logo in itself is fine .... we would be able to give a more appropriate opinion if we knew as to what layout the logo would go in to ....coz thats very important ..........so rather than working on just the logo .... 1st design a layout around it ......thn we will help to fine tune it ...

please pm me if u need any help or have any questions

Blitz

Hello, all three look the same. Would like to see the site it would go with first but IMO, logo is very busy and overpowers the name. Font looks good and colors are nice. IMO, the big star doesn't seem neccessary and your tag line "shine brighter than any domain" seems excessive. Just "SHINE BRIGHTER" might work good also. I like the ribbons with the points of light (stars) . Try with one ribbon also. Good Luck - Bob

ALG

Thanks to everyone who has inputed and even said no NP, well you got it anyways! I am stubborn like that :0)

I am going to have my designer get back to the drawing board