Yep; unforunately, the appraisal methods chart didn't help all that much. Reasons need to be posted.
@ RJ: What would you think about modifying the appraisals forum to include additional fields in replies such as "What would you pay for it?" and "What kind of website would bring in lots of $$ with this name?". These could be like the "Title" field, and would be displayed automatically inside the reply.
There's also a lot of "Low $xx, more if devved. Low $xx, more if devved. Low $xx..." etc.
I have an idea. See my thread
here.
EDIT: Updated my post with the "appraise for what you're willing to pay" method.