| Names for Commerce Name: Pat Location: Metro Detroit Join Date: Feb 2008 | Your arguments seem designed to obfuscate instead of elucidate.
The issues are simple:
ICANN makes the rules, if they find a registrar in breach of the agreement they can, and have, pulled accreditations. Your contention that the registrars can always get around this is just plain bogus.
When a name expires, it should be dropped to the available pool, that's already specified clearly in the RAA 3.7.5.
Registrars should be explicitly prohibited by the RAA from speculating in domain names. 3.7.9 needs words to the effect that "registrars are prohibited from warehousing and speculation in domain names" because some registrars are ignoring the intent. |