Thanks!! That's basically what I did.
I emailed 8 companies, and it was the first one who responded. I gave him a set buy-it-now price and the opportunity to make an offer. So far he has only offered a trade for a far less relevant domain that I wouldn't pay $5 for, so I professionally told him thanks, but I am taking money offers only. From the looks of his site and expensive products, I have no doubt that he can afford a substantial price, but I am having doubts he wants to pay anything for it as he sounds kind of cocky and wants to play games, so I will be contacting more companies. I'll keep you posted. This could get interesting.